>>
Anonymous
13/09/13(Fri)19:46
No. 6384
ID: aa068181
File
137912680312.jpg
- ( 232.19KB
, 549x791
, 877fe1c8cb83226e1639e541a366ba1c.jpg
[iqdb]
)
>>6377 >high horse Hey, I'm on the same boat with you guys, though I seem to be rowing into the wrong direction.>That makes it pretty important to her character. Arguably. But it still doesn't define nor ruin her _entire character_.>And why not? Partially because it's from the official comics ala carte, which also contain material that won't fit into any SW canon and/or is just plain silly. I would say it's not the most important character-defining material.>I don't see a single line to indicate that he was "denying" anything. If you couln't read it between the lines, I guess you missed the direct one:>I'm calling this story shit and rejecting it forever. >>6378 You probably should read it, STUPID FUCKs like myself bickering about silly stuff over the internet is always hilarious.>>6382 >I'm rejecting it forever. >I am not denying it. So, which is it? I'm guessing it's the former. :3>And you're contradicting yourself by the way Pot, kettle, black, etc.>you're belittling the canonicity status of Twilight Trio while at the same time calling me out for not accepting it's canon. Which is it? You can't have it both ways. There is no contradiction here. Its somewhat questionable canonicity is all the more reason to not think about it too seriously and not be so angry about it. Check out the aforementioned Wasu's gag comics and you'll understand what I mean about the questionable canonicity. That stuff has no place in any serious SW canon, yet it's in the official comics ala carte. There are probably other examples, but Wasu always crosses my mind first. I'm just trying to help you calm down here. I don't think TTT is good either, but I'm trying to be rational about it.>I am looking at directly what the comic in question EXPLICITLY SAYS But most of the stuff you claim isn't explicitly said in the comic. Let's see...>"became my PURPOSE IN LIFE" >Sanya became her reason to live. >Sanya instantly became her reason to live Reason to live? Nowhere in the comic. "That is my reason to fight" Literally to fight/battle the war, not metaphorically "fight on" with life, "ファイト" or anything like that. Prior to meeting Sanya, her reason for fighting was simply the Neuroi - protecting her homeland and defending mankind against Neuroi.>Like, defending Suomus, which logically should be plenty of purpose, meant nothing to her at all. >Nothing meant anything to her. ... "Of course, I wanted to protect my homeland" "And of course I felt I had a duty as a witch to protect mankind from the Neuroi invasion" I think you're reading a little bit too deep between the lines here to find the exact opposite meaning in her words.>saw her through a window once and she immediately became Nope. "After that day, we slowly got to know each other better and better" "And my once small and fragile reason soon developed into true determination" I wish Twilight Trio had elaborated on this development (among many other things) instead of skipping it with one panel and a few words. Well, you can't fit miracles into 10 pages of manga.>This is her outright saying that she had _no purpose in her life_ before she met Sanya. She is not outright saying/thinking that. You're exaggerating heavily. Claiming it was implied would be more reasonable, but that would still be your interpretation.>Feel free to share Uh? But we've been comparing interpretations all the way. Let me copypaste a small bit at random, for example's sake. Your earlier interpretation of, I would assume, Eila's thoughts on pages 3-4 or so:>Like, defending Suomus, which logically should be plenty of purpose, meant nothing to her at all. Nothing meant anything to her. Followed by my interpretation of Eila's thought on pages 3-4:>Eila was just a kid when she was drafted to the war, of course she'd feel a little lost about the whole thing. ...hey, that's exactly the kind of stuff that makes you look like an obsessive fanboy. Claiming stuff that's in direct contradiction with Eila's internal monologue and exaggerating/generalizing that view to the utmost.